New Yorkers adore their dogs, and it's easy to see why—our furry friends offer companionship, comfort, and unconditional love in one of the busiest cities in the world. However, city life comes with its own unique challenges, and certain misconceptions about dog ownership can unknowingly affect your dog's happiness and health. We're debunking five common myths many NYC dog owners believe and offering practical, actionable alternatives.
Myth #1: “Small Dogs Are Better for Apartment Living”
Reality Check:
It's a common belief among NYC dog owners that smaller dogs naturally thrive better in apartments simply because of their size. However, size isn't always an accurate indicator of adaptability. In fact, some smaller breeds—like Jack Russell Terriers, Chihuahuas, or Beagels—can be incredibly energetic and vocal, potentially causing disturbances in apartment buildings.
On the other hand, larger breeds such as Greyhounds, Great Danes, or even certain Labrador Retrievers can be surprisingly calm and relaxed indoors. It's crucial to match a dog's temperament and energy level with your living situation and lifestyle, rather than choosing based purely on size.
What to do instead:
Research breed-specific traits and temperaments through reputable resources like the American Kennel Club (AKC) or PetMD.
Consider factors such as energy level, noise tolerance, and exercise requirements.
Visit shelters or speak with breeders who understand the nuances of breeds suited to apartment life.
Myth #2: “Anyone Can Walk the Dog—Neighbors, Friends, Kids, or Any Walker”
Reality Check:
When life gets busy, many dog owners assume it’s fine to let anyone—a neighbor, a friend’s teenager, or whoever’s available—handle their dog’s walks. But relying on favors or casual arrangements can quickly become unreliable. If something goes wrong, you’re left dealing directly with individuals who aren’t professionally accountable, creating awkward situations and risking your dog’s safety. Even if you hire a solo walker, what are your options if something goes wrong? Who would you complain to?
Professional dog walking companies provide structure, reliability, and accountability that casual arrangements can’t match. However, not all dog walking companies are equal. To truly ensure your dog’s safety, health, and happiness, there are important things to look for:
Bonded & Insured: Professional dog walking businesses should always carry insurance. If they’re cutting corners on something this basic, what else might they overlook?
Employees vs. Contractors: Companies employing full-time staff (rather than independent contractors or “gig workers”) typically offer better training, oversight, and accountability.
Background Checks & Training: Always ask about employee vetting processes, background checks, and ongoing training programs.
Dog Walking Safety Protocols: Good dog walking companies should clearly communicate how they ensure safety on every walk.
What to do instead:
Work with professionally structured dog walking services, like MixyPaws’ services and rates, to ensure consistency and accountability.
Look for clear explanations about insurance, employee status, and safety procedures.
Check out our detailed guide for deeper insight: Your NYC Dog Walking Primer: Tips, Costs, Perks & What to Expect.
By choosing professional, reliable dog walkers who prioritize these key details, you set your pup up for safer and more enjoyable daily walks—and give yourself true peace of mind.
Myth #3: “Dog Training Classes Aren't Important—Dogs Naturally Adapt to City Life”
Reality Check:
Urban life can be overwhelming for dogs—think about the constant noises, crowds, and limited personal space. While some dogs seem to adjust easily, most benefit greatly from structured training classes that focus on socialization, obedience, and city-specific etiquette like walking calmly on crowded sidewalks or waiting patiently in elevators.
Training isn't merely about obedience commands; it’s about building confidence, reducing anxiety, and equipping your dog to handle urban life's unpredictability.
What to do instead:
Enroll your pup in early training classes offered by reputable trainers or local facilities.
Reinforce lessons learned during classes at home for long-term retention and consistent behavior.
Consult trainers for advice tailored specifically to living conditions in the city, emphasizing commands and behaviors critical for city life.
Myth #4: “Dog Parks Are the Best Way for Dogs to Get Exercise”
Reality Check:
Dog parks are fantastic for quick bursts of energy release and socialization, but relying solely on them for your dog's exercise can be problematic. Dog parks can sometimes pose risks such as conflicts between dogs, varying levels of owner attentiveness, and inconsistent safety standards.
Professional dog walkers, by contrast, offer structured exercise sessions tailored specifically to your dog's physical needs, temperament, and safety requirements, providing more predictable, secure, and enriching experiences.
What to do instead:
Balance dog park visits with structured walks provided by professional walkers who understand your dog's specific needs.
Explore alternative exercise and socialization strategies, such as daily professional walks or playgroups.
For great recommendations, check our guide: Best Dog Parks and Pet-Friendly Spots in NYC.
Related: Best Dog Parks in NYC
Myth #5: “Pet Insurance is a Scam”
Reality Check:
Pet insurance often gets a bad rap, labeled as an unnecessary expense or outright scam. However, veterinary care in NYC can be extraordinarily costly, especially in emergency situations. Without insurance, pet owners can face difficult financial decisions during stressful moments.
While pet insurance may not cover every single expense, having a good policy in place can significantly mitigate costs and provide peace of mind, especially in a city known for its high vet prices.
What to do instead:
Carefully research reputable pet insurance providers and policies. Many offer customizable plans to fit varying budgets and needs.
Evaluate typical NYC vet treatment costs versus monthly insurance premiums to appreciate potential savings.
Talk to your veterinarian about recommended pet insurance providers that are widely accepted at NYC clinics.
Closing Thoughts
Dispelling these myths is about much more than just clearing up misconceptions. It’s about empowering NYC dog owners with accurate information and actionable strategies that can directly improve the lives of their beloved pups. Being informed means you and your dog can better navigate the bustling city together—happy, healthy, and safe.
For personalized professional dog walking and pet care tailored to NYC life, reach out to MixyPaws. We're here to help you ensure your pup thrives in our incredible city.
